Luton councillor faces standards panel over email exchange


A Luton borough councillor has apologised for criticising her ward colleague in an email, but still faces a standards hearing this week.
A local adjudication panel is set to consider on Friday (March 6) whether Labour South councillor Charmaine Isles breached the Code of Conduct for members in an email exchange with Liberal Democrat South councillor Steve Stephens.
Councillor Isles wrote in November: “Councillor Stephens, I find your email derogatory and condescending, and I feel that’s a personal attack on me as a black female councillor.” Her email was copied to several councillors and officers, according to a report to the local adjudication panel meeting.
She wrote to the council leader, the chief executive and the monitoring officer later that day, forwarding an email exchange and registering a formal complaint against councillor Stephens, explained the report.
She said: “I feel that the tone of the email is unacceptable and unnecessary, while I think that his bullying attitude is because I am a black female.
“I’m hurt and deeply distressed by the ongoing behaviour towards me. This isn’t the first time. He’s often rude, dismissive and rude to me in public. It’s not acceptable behaviour.
“Please accept this as a formal complaint about his behaviour, attitude and misogynistic behaviour towards me. I’m highly distressed, and I will be seeking further advice regarding this matter.”
The email referenced was also in November when councillor Stephens wrote: “There’s nothing that councillor Ghulam (Abbas) can do that’s not being looked into by the various officers already putting in much effort.
“While you’ve been involved in the case, I have also been actively trying to support (a resident). I object to the involvement of another councillor in this way, especially without consulting me first. As I’ve said already, this can cause confusion.”
On the same day, the monitoring officer received an email from councillor Stephens, saying: “I’ve a serious complaint to make against councillor Isles.
“As you can see, councillor Isles is basically accusing me of making a personal racist attack on her. There’s not one shred of evidence that I’ve ever been racist in either word or action, either towards her or anyone else. I find this defamatory in the extreme.”
Councillor Stephens forwarded the exchange of emails, but “with the crucial addition of an email of November 27” from councillor Isles, added the report.
The monitoring officer wrote to councillor Stephens to acknowledge his complaint. He contacted councillor Isles, confirming: “I’ve given careful consideration to your complaint and to the email exchange that preceded it.
“I can find nothing in the tone or content of councillor Stephens’ email to you that could justify serious allegations of racism, misogyny and bullying. Unless you can provide evidence to substantiate those allegations, I’ll have to dismiss the complaint.
“The matter is made more complicated as you responded to councillor Stephens’ email and made those same allegations in public by including several other persons in the exchange. He’s made a complaint against you.
“Unless evidence can be brought to substantiate those allegations, there appears to be a clear breach of the Code of Conduct for members. I’d like to explore the possibility of an informal resolution to this matter.”
Both councillors agreed to explore the potential for an informal resolution, but no satisfactory conclusion was reached. Councillor Isles issued her apology,
The panel is recommended to decide what action, if any, should be taken about the complaint through its available options.