With more than 220 votes cast, the summer signing from Northampton Town took over 40 per cent of the poll.
Popular centre half Steve McNulty came second, while leading scorer and golden boot winner Andre Gray was third.
Guttridge was a hugely influential figure in Town’s promotion this season, scoring 13 times in 33 appearances.
He was forced to miss the title run-in though after injuring his metatarsal during the 3-0 win over Alfreton Town.
Full results: Luke Guttridge 40.17%; Steve McNulty 25.33%; Andre Gray 10.04%; Scott Griffiths 7.86%; Mark Tyler 4.8%; Paul Benson 3.49%; Jonathan Smith 2.62%; Fraser Franks 1.31%; Alex Lawless 0.87%; Ronnie Henry 0.87%; Pelly Ruddock Mpanzu 0.87%; Jake Howells 0.44%; Cameron McGeehan 0.44%; Matt Robinson 0.44%; Alex Lacey 0.44%.