Town keeper reveals he relied on his instincts during shoot-out success
Shea saves two penalties as Hatters claim an extra point
Hatters keeper James Shea revealed he had to rely on his instincts during the Jersey Mike’s Trophy penalty shoot-out victory at Colchester United on Saturday.
The 35-year-old was starting his third successive match for the club, as when it finished 1-1 after 90 minutes, it meant both sides took a point, before having the opportunity to grab an extra one by winning on spotkicks. Jordan Clark tucked his away, before Dan Gore’s attempt was saved, but Devante Cole and Jake Richards were both able to find the net for the visitors.
During that sequence, Shea saved the hosts’ second attempt when he stopped Frankie Terry’s weak shot as at 3-3, the ex-Arsenal youngsters sprang to his left to repel Kian Connolly’s poor effort from the U’s fifth kick, allowing centre half Mads Andersen to step up and win it for the Hatters.


Although there was some method to his approach at keeping the ball out, Shea admitted that due to the lack of knowledge of those taking them, he had to make up his mind on the spot, saying: “That’s my job, try and save the pens. We do our homework no matter what game and thankfully we won. Pilks (Kevin Pilkington, head of goalkeeping) does a lot of work, gives me my bottle and he tells me where he thinks we could go. To be fair, there were a couple we didn’t actually know about where they made so many changes, but thankfully it worked.
"You try and get that feeling of where you think they could go with their body shape, the way the run up to the ball, try and stare at them in the eye, see if they’re looking a certain way. I’m not going to lie, ninety percent of it is probably about feel if I’m honest with you. I had a couple of feelings, especially with the second one, that he was going to go to my left. Some days it works, some days it doesn’t, thankfully it worked today.”
Shea’s record from the spot for Town hadn’t been the best over the years, saving just two in his near 10-year long career at Kenilworth Road, although one saw the rebound hammered in by Preston's Paul Gallagher. He couldn’t prevent Fleetwood from going through in the FA Cup last term, Luton losing 3-1 in the shootout, so this time he was pleased to come out on the right side, continuing: “I lost one last year to Fleetwood, and that was disappointing, but it’s always nice to win a shootout.
"Don’t get me wrong, it’s not going to change the season or anything like that, but it’s always nice to save a couple. It puts a bit of confidence in and we move on now, build some momentum into next week. Any time you win a game of football, no matter how it comes about, you’re happy. I would have liked it if we had won it in the 90 minutes, but it wasn’t meant to be.”
Shea had been looking for his second successive clean sheet in the competition, after a 6-0 thrashing of Ipswich Town U21s recently, but despite Town leading late on through Devante Cole's clinical finish, they were unable to keep out their fourth tier opponents, substitute Bradley Ihionvien scoring from close range in the 90th minute.
Manager Jack Wilshere spoke of his disappointment with the way his side were breached afterwards, as Shea himself was also annoyed, saying: “It’s a tough one as they’ve come, they were in a low block really, they put 11 men behind the ball and it’s tough as we haven’t played for 10 days. A lot of changes as well, the boys have gone away, some have come back, so it is tough to get going again.
“The last 10 minutes where we had a lot of possession and we scored a really good goal, we made them come out a little bit, but we’ve got to manage that better. They get their goal and the boys that stood up took their pens well. When we score a goal late on we’ve got to try and see it out, but we won the game, that’s the main thing.”
Although Luton weren’t at their best during the contest, struggling to break down the U’s, to get the extra point and cement their place at the top of the group was important for Shea, who knows how good the competition can be having played at Wembley for the first time in his career during a 3-1 victory over Stockport County in the final to lift the cup last term.
He added: “It’s a great competition, probably one of the best days of my career last year in the final, and I’d love to be a part of it again like everyone else in there, so it starts now. It’s a tough one at the moment, it gives us a chance to swap a few players about, gives everyone some game time, but the longer you’re in it, it gets more of a competition. Anytime you can get to Wembley is a massive occasion, so another step forward hopefully.”