OPINION: Is Luton’s first Muslim woman leader being judged by the same standards?

Nineteen years versus fifteen weeks. Former Dunstable Mayor Louise O’Riordan questions why Cllr Tahmina Saleem, Luton’s first Muslim woman Leader, is already facing an attempt to remove her from office.

Then Mayor of Dunstable Louise O’Riordan with then Mayor of Luton Cllr Tahmina Saleem at the Justice Service in Bedford, September 2024. placeholder image
Then Mayor of Dunstable Louise O’Riordan with then Mayor of Luton Cllr Tahmina Saleem at the Justice Service in Bedford, September 2024. | Louise O’Riordan

There is one question I keep coming back to as I watch events unfolding at Luton Council:

What has Cllr Tahmina Saleem actually done wrong?

St Patrick’s Day Parade organised by Luton Irish Forum 2025placeholder image
St Patrick’s Day Parade organised by Luton Irish Forum 2025 | Louise O’Riordan

Hazel Simmons led Luton Council continuously for almost 19 years, from 2007 until she stepped down in May 2026.

I have looked for a comparable attempt by councillors to remove Hazel Simmons as Leader during those 19 years. I cannot find one.

Tahmina Saleem became Leader on 19 May 2026.

On 3 September — just 15 weeks and two days later — a motion was moved proposing “that the council leader be removed from office”.

It progressed by 24 votes to 21.

That is an extraordinary contrast: almost 19 years versus 15 weeks.

And I think the people of Luton are entitled to ask why.

Where is the misconduct? Where is the dishonesty? Where is the serious failure of leadership that warrants removing a council leader less than four months after she took office?

If there is a substantive case against Tahmina Saleem, those seeking to remove her should make it clearly and publicly.

Because what is plainly visible is considerable political upheaval.

Luton Council currently comprises 22 Labour, 14 Liberal Democrat, six Independent Alliance, three Conservative and three Independent councillors.

The Liberal Democrats, Independent Alliance and Conservatives combined their votes to progress the move against Tahmina.

There is also some important recent context.

Former Luton Council Leader David Franks left the Liberal Democrats in August after more than 40 years with the party. It was reported that his departure followed the Lib Dem group’s nomination of a Reform UK councillor for a committee position.

Whatever your political allegiance, a former council leader walking away from his political home of more than four decades over the direction it is taking is significant.

There is another context we should not ignore.

Tahmina Saleem is Luton’s first Muslim woman Leader.

That does not mean that opposition to her is automatically sexist, racist or Islamophobic. Nor would I make such an allegation without evidence.

But there is relevant history here.

In December 2023, during a House of Commons debate on tackling Islamophobia, Luton MP Rachel Hopkins spoke specifically about Muslim women councillors in Luton.

She told Parliament that Luton Labour had “not only a majority of women councillors, but, within that, a majority of Muslim women councillors”, before adding that “they have been targeted for abuse”, which she described as “simply unacceptable”.

Those words are not rumour or political gossip. They are on the parliamentary record.

So when Luton’s first Muslim woman Leader finds herself facing an attempt to remove her after just 15 weeks, while her predecessor led for almost 19 years without any comparable removal attempt that I can find, I believe it is entirely legitimate to ask an uncomfortable question:

Is Tahmina Saleem being judged by the same standards as the Leader who came before her?

Asking that question is not the same as alleging that every councillor supporting her removal is motivated by prejudice.

It is asking whether conscious or unconscious double standards could be at play — and whether a Muslim woman who reaches the highest political office in Luton is being afforded a fair opportunity to demonstrate what she can do.

I know Tahmina personally.

We served as Mayors of neighbouring Luton and Dunstable during 2024/25 and deliberately built a friendship because we shared a belief that our neighbouring communities should be brought closer together, not driven further apart.

We come from different backgrounds and different faiths, but we shared the same belief that communities should build bridges, not divisions.

The woman I have come to know is honest, compassionate, intelligent, service-driven and deeply committed to her community. She has a strong sense of justice and integrity.

That is not something a political party has asked me to say. It is my assessment from knowing her and working alongside her.

I am not a Labour member, and this is not about defending the Labour Party.

It is about fairness and good public service.

I have heard the argument that the attempt to remove Tahmina is “not personal”.

But the motion itself seeks to remove a particular individual from the office of Leader.

That makes a very simple question unavoidable:

Why her?

If the answer concerns something Tahmina has personally done, tell the people of Luton what it is.

Not grievances about the Labour Party.

Not disagreements about events before she became Leader.

Not political point-scoring.

What has Tahmina Saleem actually done in those 15 weeks that makes her unfit to lead?

Women — including Muslim women — are regularly encouraged to enter politics, step forward into public life and take leadership positions.

But encouraging women to reach the table is meaningless if, once they arrive, we do not ensure they are afforded the same opportunity to lead and are judged according to the same standards as those who came before them.

Hazel Simmons led Luton Council for almost 19 years, without any comparable attempt to remove her that I can find.

Tahmina Saleem faced one after 15 weeks.

That disparity does not, on its own, tell us why.

But it certainly entitles us to ask.

And unless those seeking Tahmina’s removal can give the people of Luton a substantive answer about what she has actually done wrong, I believe Luton’s first Muslim woman Leader deserves something remarkably simple:

The opportunity to lead.

Louise O’Riordan is a former Mayor of Dunstable (2024/25) and served concurrently with Cllr Tahmina Saleem during her term as Mayor of Luton.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1891
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice