To see how the Hatters rated during what was an emotional and downright wonderful afternoon at Wembley Stadium, see below.
13. Fred Onyedinma (SUB): 7
Came on for Doughty as he went to the left wingback role and looked to get at his man when Luton managed to get the ball wide to him. Able to create some decent crossing opportunities during normal time and then extra time, but Town just lacked the legs to reach them. His pace getting back prevented the Sky Blues being able to counter as they would have wanted. Photo: Liam Smith
14. Luke Berry (SUB): 7.5
Great to see him on at Wembley and showed Undertaker-like powers of recovery to get up from an aerial clash that appeared to wipe him out. Almost won it with the last action, heading wide from a free kick. Stepped up as the fifth penalty taker and made absolutely no mistake, powering into the side-netting. Photo: Liam Smith
15. Joe Taylor (SUB): 7.5
On for the last half of extra time, it looked like he was going to be the hero when nicking the ball of Panzo and going through to beat Wilson with time ticking away. However, VAR spoilt his big momemt, with handball chalking it off. Managed to put that behind him to show nerves of steel when scoring in the shoot-out after going second. Photo: Liam Smith
16. Dan Potts (SUB): 7.5
With Osho cramping up, one of Luton’s longest serving players was called for to get his moment at Wembley. Prevented any late attacks and then stepped up when penalties went to sudden death, fooling Wilson and sidefooting into the bottom corner, before City missed to spark scenes of sheer jubilation. Photo: Liam Smith