The Hatters had seen off Leeds United, Leicester City, Ipswich Town, Blackpool and Norwich City to reach Wembley, but in front of 100,000 people, were 2-0 down inside 15 minutes. Dave Pacey pulled one back just after the hour mark, but Town couldn't find an equaliser in what remains the only time they have reached this stage of the competition. Below, the Luton News takes a look at just who lined up for Luton that day.
1. Ron Baynham
Long serving keeper kept two clean sheets in the competition, against Blackpool and Norwich City, but was beaten twice at Wembley.
2. Brendan McNally
Irish international joined Luton Town in 1956, staying for eight years. Involved in the tackle that saw Forest goalscorer Roy Dwight, cousin of Sir Elton John, break his leg in the final. Left for Cambridge City in 1963.
3. Ken Hawkes
Joined Luton in 1957, featuring over 100 times for the Hatters as his cross set up Pacey for Town's goal at Wembley. Moved to Peterborough United in 1961, heading to Bedford Town and Dunstable Town later in his career.
4. John Groves
Turned professional at Luton on his 17th birthday and went on to feature 251 times for the Hatters. Left in 1963 for Bournemouth & Boscombe where he ended his career.